Blog

In any collaborative software project, clear and informative Git commit messages are vital. They serve as a log that explains why certain changes were made, making it easier to understand the evolution of a codebase. A well-written commit message not only helps your future self but also your collaborators in understanding the context of a change. In this blog, we’ll explore the best practices for writing effective commit messages that enhance the clarity and usability of your Git history.

Why Are Commit Messages Important?

Git commit messages provide a history of what changes were made to the project and why they were implemented. This is particularly helpful when:

• Debugging issues and finding when a bug was introduced.
• Reviewing the codebase to understand past decisions.
• Collaborating with a team, making code reviews and pull requests more effective.

Structure of a Good Commit Message

A well-structured commit message typically has two parts:

1. Subject Line: A brief summary of the change.
2. Body (optional but recommended): A more detailed explanation of the change, especially if it’s complex or affects multiple files.

1. Subject Line (50 characters or less)

The subject line should briefly describe what the change does. It should be concise but clear enough to understand without further context. Follow these guidelines:

• Use the imperative mood: Write as if you’re giving commands to complete the task, e.g., “Add user authentication” or “Fix login bug.”
• Keep it short: Aim for around 50 characters or less. If it’s too long, refine the wording.
• Capitalize the first word: Proper capitalization improves readability.
• Avoid ending with a period: Single-line summaries don’t need punctuation.

2. Body (wrap at 72 characters per line)

While the subject line is brief, the body can provide detailed context:

• Explain the why and how: If the “what” is in the subject, the body should explain why the change was necessary and how it was implemented.
• Use bullet points or lists: If the commit touches multiple areas or files, breaking down the changes into bullet points improves clarity.
• Reference related issues or tickets: If your commit addresses a bug or a feature request, mention the issue number. For example: “Closes #345.”
• Separate body from subject: Always leave a blank line between the subject and the body for better formatting.

Example of a Well-Written Commit Message

Add password strength validation for user registration

- Implement client-side password validation
- Enforce minimum password length and special character requirement
- Show error messages for invalid passwords
- Closes #123: Users can now create more secure passwords

Best Practices for Writing Commit Messages

1. Commit Often, but Not Excessively

• Commit after each meaningful change. It’s easier to understand and review smaller, atomic changes than large, sprawling commits.
• Avoid committing incomplete code. Each commit should represent a working state.

1. Be Specific and Clear

• Avoid vague messages like “fix bug” or “update file.” Instead, describe what was fixed: “Fix null pointer exception in login function.”
• Use consistent language. If you use terms like “refactor,” “add,” “fix,” make sure to use them consistently.

1. Use Conventional Commit Formatting
   Some teams follow a specific format like Conventional Commits, which categorizes commits into types like feat, fix, or chore. For example:

   feat: add user authentication
   fix: resolve signup page crash
   chore: update dependencies

4. Focus on the Why, Not Just the What

• The code itself shows what changed, but the commit message should explain why you made that change. This is especially important for decisions that might not be obvious at first glance.

4. Group Related Changes

• Each commit should address a single concern. If you’re adding a feature and fixing a bug, consider breaking these into separate commits.

4. Avoid Commit Noise

• Don’t clutter your commit history with messages like “fix typo” or “WIP.” Use git commit --amend to combine small fixes into a single meaningful commit.

What to Avoid in Commit Messages

• One-word commits: Messages like “update” or “fix” don’t provide useful information.
• WIP (Work in Progress): While it’s common during development, WIP commits should be squashed or removed before merging.
• Leaving commit messages empty: It’s important to describe the purpose of the change, even if it’s a small one.

Automating Commit Message Guidelines

You can automate or enforce commit message standards using tools like:

• Git Hooks: Pre-commit or commit-msg hooks can validate commit messages and ensure they meet your team’s standards.
• Linting: Tools like commitlint help enforce specific commit message conventions, such as Conventional Commits.

Conclusion

Writing clear, concise, and informative commit messages is an essential skill for every developer. It ensures that your project’s history remains meaningful and useful for future developers or collaborators. By following the best practices outlined in this blog, you can improve the clarity of your Git logs and contribute to a more maintainable codebase.

By adopting a consistent and informative approach to commit messages, you’ll make life easier for your team and yourself when revisiting or debugging code in the future.